Chasing Symptoms
Jewish publications and thought leaders, especially since COVID and October 7 th , have identified many “problems” that need to be solved, such as declining synagogue membership, support for Israel, and rising rates of intermarriage. These problems are often accompanied by a call for new, dramatic solutions which are advertised as innovative upgrades to Jewish life and education. Many of these “innovations” are problematic for four reasons. First, they are closely related to, if not exact copies, of things that have been tried in the past. Second, they treat symptoms rather than underlying problems. Third, they are “hydroponic” – rootless and floating on their own, often educationally and structurally disconnected from other programming in their institutions. Fourth, they lack a plausibility structure, which may be the deeper problem organizations need to address. According to Peter Berger and Arnold Eisen, plausibility structures describe the sociocultural contexts tha...